Why People Visit Your Website But Never Book a Call | From Click to Client

From Click to Client Podcast · Episode 95

Why People Visit Your Website But Never Book a Call

Website traffic and no booked calls? Before you rewrite your messaging, find out where people are really dropping off.

Episode cover art

Episode 95

Why People Visit Your Website But Never Book a Call

Loading the player…

🎧 Apple Podcasts  |  Spotify  |  YouTube

About This Episode

You've got people visiting your website. Your calendar is still quiet. So you start wondering if your messaging is broken, and you're one bad week away from rewriting the whole thing.

In this Q&A, my right hand and podcast producer, Jaime Smoody, turned the tables on me and asked the questions we hear most. I share how to tell if your website marketing has a messaging problem or something else entirely, the client story where hundreds of people clicked Book a Call and still didn't book, and what to do if you're embarrassed to send anyone to your website at all.

What You'll Walk Away With

  • The first number I check before I'll call anything a messaging problem
  • Where hundreds of interested people disappeared after clicking Book a Call, and the simple fix
  • Why your website should work as your top sales employee
  • A website copy hack for finding words that build trust, and why AI-written sites break it

Questions This Episode Answers

How do I know if my problem is my messaging or something else in my business?
Start by naming the problem, then look at your traffic. If only a few people visit your website each day, there isn't enough data to judge your messaging. I look for at least 50 to 100 visitors a day, and if good-quality traffic is arriving and nobody takes action, then it's worth refining the message.

Why do people click Book a Call but never book?
Often the scheduler itself is in the way. In one client's case, hundreds of people clicked the button and then left because the booking page was full of long paragraphs re-selling the call. They were already sold, so remove the hurdles: show the calendar, keep a few qualifying questions, and cut the rest.

What should I do if I'm embarrassed to send people to my website?
You should be proud to send people to your website, because it should be doing the bulk of the selling for you. Go back to recorded calls with your best-fit clients and use their words, so readers feel like you're in their head.

Should I use AI to write my website copy?
Use AI as a tool, not the one in charge. Readers can often tell when a website was written by AI, and when they sense it, trust breaks and they leave. Learn a messaging framework like StoryBrand so you know what an excellent homepage needs, then guide the tool toward it.

"They're already sold when they click on the Book a Call button. You do not have to re-convince them or re-sell them on this call."

~ Kris Jones

Connect with Kris Jones

Kris Jones

Kris Jones is the founder of Red Door Stories, a Certified StoryBrand Guide, and a messaging strategist who helps service providers, coaches, and consultants clarify their marketing message so they can attract consistent clients. Her core belief: simplicity is a strategic advantage. Less noise, clearer message, more traction.

Book a Growth Gameplan Call
Take the Free Client Attraction Scorecard
Follow on Instagram
Subscribe to Kris's YouTube Channel and Learn How to Attract More Clients

Meet Jaime Smoody

Jaime Smoody

Jaime Smoody is the founder of Feeling Golden Services, where she helps entrepreneurs and coaches get their message heard and their back end handled. She produces podcasts for business owners who want a consistent show without it taking over their week, builds GoHighLevel systems that keep leads and clients moving smoothly, and created the Adaptive Quiz Funnel. A former teacher based in Mesa, Arizona, Jaime brings calm, clear direction to every build so her clients can focus on showing up and leading.

Take the Podcast Production Health Check
Follow on Instagram
Follow on Facebook

📖 Episode transcript

Kris: [00:00:00] I am so delighted to have my right hand here today, Jaime Smoody. She has been on the f- show before, and we might as well just pull out the champagne, because we have the best time doing these episodes. Oh, heck yeah. it's pretty fun, because we get a lot of questions from a lot of people, and what we do on these episodes is gather those questions together, and then Jaime and I talk about them one by one. So you are in for- Great ... a treat today. Jaime, how are you doing?

Jaime: [00:00:32] I'm excited. We're here. You know I love this format. We get to turn the tables on Kris Jones, and get all of her expertise in answering these great questions. So- Yes ... you ready to dive into it, or what?

Kris: [00:00:43] I'm ready to dive in. I just closed my office door because I have a new puppy here. I have a 14-year-old puppy and a 14-week-old puppy, and they like to play together. So they're like, I can hear them in the background r- rambling around the living room, and I'm just I don't know what's gonna happen during this hour behind this door, but, it doesn't matter. Be here now.

Jaime: [00:01:08] you should probably share their names with the audience, though, don't you think? They... that's always-

Kris: [00:01:12] Yes ...

Jaime: [00:01:12] it's the first thing I wanna know when someone says they have a dog or a cat is- So- ...

Kris: [00:01:16] what are their names? Yes. I have my 14-year-old puppy... he's not a puppy. My 14-year-old m- old man is named Henry Blue, and my new puppy, who's a little girl, is named Charlie. Ooh. And my son Jude, it's really his dog, and he wanted to name her middle name the same as his middle name, which is River.

Jaime: [00:01:41] Oh.

Kris: [00:01:42] So it's Jude River and Charlie River.

Jaime: [00:01:44] Oh my gosh, I love that.

Kris: [00:01:46] Yeah.

Jaime: [00:01:47] That's really cute.

Kris: [00:01:48] Yeah. Pretty fun.

Jaime: [00:01:49] Okay. All right. I think that leads perfectly into our first question.

Kris: [00:01:53] Good segue. Perfect segue. Great

Jaime: [00:01:54] segue. All right, here we go.

Q1: Messaging vs. Other Business Problems

Jaime: [00:01:56] Question number one, Kris. We have, "How do I know if my problem is my messaging or something else in my business?"

Kris: [00:02:06] my number one question to you would be, what problem are you having? is it that people aren't booking calls with you? Is it that no one's taking any action on the website? Is it that your calendar is just quiet and your revenue has flattened out? so the number one thing is identify the problem. When I get this question, the first thing I ask is- How many people are coming to your website? Because very often, someone will revamp their messaging, they'll, do an overhaul, whether it's with me or AI or somebody else. they'll change their messaging and then nothing will happen, right? maybe a month goes by and they're like, "Okay, this isn't working. I'm gonna change it again. I'm gonna change it again." And they keep throwing spaghetti at the wall, which ultimately is just really a frustrating experience and- ... a waste of your time. So the way we know if your messaging is working or not is are you getting enough people to come to your website every day? And if you're a solopreneur or a coach or a consultant or self-employed, anybody who works with clients, it's really important that you're driving traffic to the website, and y- you're... the marketing activities that you are doing is driving eyeballs to your website. for example, if you've got one, two or three people coming to your website per day, and they're on the website, we don't know where they came from. Were they really trying to find you- ... or did they just... did you get served up in a random Google search? So number one, how many people are coming to the website every day, and how many of those people are your ideal client? How long are they staying on the website? Are they actually engaging with the website? So if you are, somebody who has a website and you have a plan for driving eyeballs to the website and people are coming, I'm ideally looking for at least 50 to 100 people per day coming to your website v- from various sources. It could be from social media. It could be from a podcast episode. It could be you emailing your list and driving people to the website from there. There's so many different ways. I talk about often the whole, your website's the, the sun of your marketing universe, right? Yeah. driving eyeballs to the website, and if, if you're getting a lot of good quality traffic to your website and people aren't taking action- Then it's a messaging problem. it's really worth looking at your messaging and making some refinements, and ways that you can make refinements are to really revisit the calls that you had with your ideal clients, people that you ended up working with or maybe that were a really good fit and didn't end up working with you. Go back to those calls and really tune into the words that those people are using. We want them to think you're in their head. And then take that knowledge and infuse it into your website. So that's- ... where I would focus first. There's one more thing I wanna share here. this happened with a client of mine actually, who has a pretty massive following. So it was a no-brainer. They're like, "We're gonna redo our website messaging." And then they had a lot of different ways that broadcast that information and drive eyeballs to their website. And so they got in touch not long ago, and they were like, "It's weird. Nobody is booking a call, and something m- must be wrong with our messaging." And I was like, "Okay. let... Could be, right? That's a, a possibility, and before we go revamping the messaging, let's do some more investigating." And so what they found out is that with one post that they did, and I can't remember if it was a social media post or an email that they had sent out. I think it was an email that they had sent to their list. They drove people to their offer, meaning they drove people to their home page, and I said, "First off, let's l- look at your traffic." Their traffic was amazing. lot, a lot of eyeballs going to the website, nobody taking action. When we dug a little bit deeper, what we found is that hundreds of people had clicked on the book a call button- But there was so much text that they had to sift through in order to book that call that people were jumping ship and bailing. So-

Jaime: [00:07:01] Oh ...

Kris: [00:07:02] the traffic was there, the messaging was dialed in because people aren't gonna They're not gonna click on the Book a Call button if the messaging isn't totally resonating with them.

Jaime: [00:07:12] Yeah.

Kris: [00:07:13] But thankfully, through data and analytics, we realized, oh, they're clicking on that call. They wanna book a call. But there was So many words on the actual scheduler itself that people were i- weren't patient enough to actually go through that. And the first thing I told them to do is just remove all the barriers between someone coming to your website and them booking a call with you. If your main call to action is to book a call, remove all the hurdles. this is not the hurdle race. remove the hurdles. We want them to have a- Yeah ... very clear path. click on the Book a Call. They get presented your calendar. They find a spot in your calendar. If you have a few qualifying questions, sure, qualify people with questions, but don't make them sift through, multiple, like a very, very long multiple paragraph, agreement or preparation, whatever. In this case, it was like, how you know this call is right for you, preparation for the call. This is information about what you're gonna get on the call. And what I told my client was they're already sold on the call when they click on the book a call button. They're already sold. You do not have to re-convince them or re-sell them on this call after they've clicked on the book a call button. Yeah. you know how that feels when you're, like, sold on something and you're ready to move forward- Yeah ... and then somebody comes in and they're, like, trying to sell you on it again. It's almost a bit of a turn-off. You're like, "Oh, I w- I was already sold, but now that you're trying to convince me, it's... I- and now you're taking up my time. here, just, I'm ready to book." So-

Jaime: [00:09:00] Yeah, that's a dif- different issue for a different day to go

Kris: [00:09:02] over Different i- issue for a different day, but all that to say, that was a very long answer to a pretty simple question, but

Jaime: [00:09:11] yeah. Yeah, I think I had a couple questions in there, but now I'm not so sure I remember what they were. I know what the first one was. Yeah. the first one was

Q2: Website Hacks & Resources

Jaime: [00:09:33] people may be listening and thinking, when you said that we should be sending people to our website, people may be thinking, "Oh, but I don't really like my website. I- Yeah ... hate... Ugh." they don't feel like it gets the job done, right?

Kris: [00:09:36] do you have any maybe, resources or tips or things that people can check out that would, give them some official- Hacks?

Jaime: [00:09:48] Yes.

Kris: [00:09:49] Hacks.

Jaime: [00:09:51] That they can do on their website just to even- Yeah ... make 'em feel a little more comfortable sharing their website with others.

Kris: [00:09:58] Yeah. This is such a common thing. I just talked, to Megan Caldwell. She was on my podcast earlier this week, and she was also a client of mine, and she used to do so many acrobatic maneuvers to avoid sending people to her website. She would be like, "No, just email me instead," or, "Go to my Instagram." and ultimately what it came down to is she, just like you said, she was embarrassed of her website. And so many people are. And so the number one thing I wanna share is that you should be proud to send people to your website. Yeah. And you should be confident that it's gonna do the bulk of the selling for you. Yes, you still need to get on a call with a potential client because you wanna qualify them, they wanna qualify you, just make sure there's a connection, but your website should really be doing the job of acting as your top sales employee. That's what it should do. And I think so often we get bogged down by all the things that we have to do as business owners, that We forget that our website actually could and should be doing this type of important work. And when it's doing that work, what a load off for you. then you really can focus on the things that matter the most.

Jaime: [00:11:18] Yeah.

Kris: Real quick, if this show has helped you gain some clarity, hit follow on Apple or Spotify. It takes two seconds, and you'll get the next episode as soon as it drops. It also helps other people find the show and allows me to keep creating this helpful content for you at no charge As far as, a hack. I love that word, hack.

Jaime: [00:11:40] Yeah, we love hacks ...

Kris: [00:11:41] we love a good hack. I, honestly, I think the best thing to do is to listen to, go back to those calls, that is your source of truth. Go back to those recorded calls that you've had with potential clients. I think another thing you can do is just pay attention when you're out on the web and browsing the internet, and you come across people that you like what they're doing or they're resonating with you. keep a list of those people, and ideally, they're not even in your industry. But for whatever reason, you're resonating with what they're saying. pay attention to that, and you can really dissect once you have three or five of those, you can compare them and dissect, what is it about these websites that, is making me trust them, connect with them, inspiring me to take the next step, to take action? You can even put those five websites into Claude or ChatGPT and say, "Hey, what do these five websites have in common, and what can I do to apply that same level of, connection," really is what I'm going for- these days because if you- If you're out and about on the internet, and you're gathering a bunch of AI-built or AI-written websites, everyone is starting to sound the same. Yes. And it's really likely that the people that you're resonating with aren't using AI to write their website. Because if a potential client can get a hint that y- that it's been written by AI, trust is broken, and they will leave your website. we have to be so careful these days. And I l- I love AI. Jaime and I both, we appreciate AI for what it's good for, and writing copy that feels truly aligned with who you are, and your personality, and your expertise, but also your humanness. Like, all of that needs to come through, and I like AI to do other things than writing my website 'cause it's just too important. It's too, too important. But you also have to know how to write a website. you also have to know... You have to be able to find the words, right? To really find the right words, but you have to know what's the end goal. what's the finish line that you're trying to get to? Not just a finished webpage, but, like, how do I know this strategy is set up to work period? and so that involves some education on messaging frameworks, and StoryBrand framework is one I'm a big believer of, as I'm sure but it's the difference between getting on a really powerful horse and being able to guide that horse around the track and win the race versus getting on a wild stallion hitting the butt of that horse and letting it go wherever it wants to go, and that's what I think most people are doing these days with AI is just letting it be in charge and guiding you versus you using it as a tool, knowing where you're trying to get to and what an excellent homepage actually needs to be

Jaime: [00:15:08] so Kris, what's another hack? it, again, just going back to someone who is not sure what changes- Yeah and is looking maybe for, some quick fixes or just- Yeah ... anything they can do to just make it better now.

Kris: [00:15:23] Yeah.

Jaime: [00:15:23] do you have another resource or anything for them?

Kris: [00:15:25] I do actually. If you do not have time to read an entire book on messaging strategy, and you just have a full plate, and you wanna get right to the heart of what I'm talking about, you can go to my YouTube channel at youtube/reddoorstory, and there I do a live story brand makeover. we go from a- Yeah ... a website that was not getting this woman clients to in real time showing her what changes she needs to implement on her website in order to turn it into a story brand website that's gonna actually get you clients.

Jaime: [00:16:05] I think As your podcast producer, I'm pretty sure we also have a podcast episode where you walked through someone else's website, so we can link that in the show notes. Yes. And then we'll put a link to the YouTube channel so you can find this other website makeover. but that might be a good place for people to start if they're wanting to, see and hear- Yeah ... you in the moment, teaching someone.

Kris: [00:16:25] There's a, a podcast where I just literally walk through a great website from top to bottom in kind of a before and after. So that's... We'll put the, we'll put a link to that episode, and then the YouTube one is actually pretty brand new, so that's a fun one if you have time to actually watch the transformation. It's pretty cool.

Jaime: [00:16:48] That's great. Okay, Kris.

Fun Question: Rollercoasters

Jaime: [00:16:50] I think that's all the time we have for formal questions. However, if you listened the last time, then you know that I have to throw in a little funsies at the end here. So my question for you today is, are you a rollercoaster person, and have you ever been?

Kris: [00:17:08] Yes. I 100% am a rollercoaster person. I have always been, like, if I go to the fair or I go to a theme park, which one is the scariest ride, and I go to that one first. And thankfully, my eight-year-old son is wired the same way. He's like a dopamine dude.

Jaime: [00:17:29] So

Kris: [00:17:29] to this day? To this day, yeah. I took him to Legoland- To this day, okay ... last, last summer, and he had outgrown it. He's eight years old. He was, like, ready for more thrilling rides, so we're gonna have to up-level my game a little bit with our next vacation. So yes, rides, I love them. I love the thrilling rides, always have. and then same thing for scary movies.

Jaime: [00:17:56] Oh.

Kris: [00:17:57] Yeah.

Jaime: [00:17:59] Do- definitely do not do that. I do not do that. No scary movies. A- and actually, I will just share the reason that I don't do scary movies is 'cause I remember in fifth grade, I was at a sleepover, and we watched my very first scary movie, which was Nightmare on Elm Street. oh my gosh, I'm totally dating myself now. for those of you Gen X-ers out there, I- you can relate, I'm sure. Yeah. yeah, ruined me for life. Do not watch scary movies.

Kris: [00:18:26] Yeah. Okay. I guess we're a little bit different in that way.

Jaime: [00:18:29] Yeah. And that's why we fit so well together, and we work so... You have the thrill-seeker. I used to ride roller coasters, and then maybe 10 years ago I tried one, and as soon as I got off, I was like, "Okay, I think that was my last one." I immediately knew it was over.

Kris: [00:18:45] I know what you mean. I can't just walk off and carry on in the way that I used to be able to. It has-

Jaime: [00:18:52] Okay

Kris: [00:18:53] it hasn't stopped me from doing them, but I did notice, I would say maybe 10 years ago, that I just started to feel, I need a little bit of time to recover after this. Yeah. I'm a little off-kilter. But, it hasn't stopped me.

Jaime: [00:19:10] Okay.

Kris: [00:19:10] All right.

Jaime: [00:19:11] Nothing's gonna stop you. Oh, s- if you're not watching on YouTube, you can't see our dance moves, sorry. Or actually, Kris' dance moves, not mine, but... Okay,

Kris: [00:19:22] Kris. Well- Jaime,

Closing & Aha Moment

Kris: [00:19:23] I have a question for you before we hop off.

Jaime: [00:19:25] Oh, okay. If

Kris: [00:19:26] you could... If you walked away... you and I work together a lot, so you're a pro. But if you had one aha from today, what would it be?

Jaime: [00:19:34] my i- my aha would be to go back to my website and really look to make sure that I'm making that emotional connection with the person who's reading it.

Kris: [00:19:47] Yeah. Make sure your Jaime-ness, your humanness- ... is really shining. I feel like, from my perspective, you do a really great job of this. I feel like your brand over the last year has up-leveled in so many ways, but what's really cool is that your, you've definitely up-leveled, like it's more polished, but it's not polished in the way that it's taken the humanness out of the brand. Yes. It's actually more human than ever, and more- Yes aligned with you and who you are, your playfulness and your-

Jaime: [00:20:22] Yes ...

Kris: [00:20:23] your spunk, and that's been really fun to witness.

Jaime: [00:20:27] I, that is really important to me, and it m- may be important to, our listeners out there. When you create a website and you create some place for someone to come learn about you, like I don't want it to be all formal and, because that's not how I am. my business is Feeling Golden Services. I want you feeling golden when you're working with me. we have fun. there's, enjoyment and relief and excitement, and so I just feel like my website needs to show my personality, too.

Kris: [00:20:57] Yeah. Yeah. And it does.

Jaime: [00:20:59] So if you're listening and you go look at your website and see if it's showing your personality, drop it in the comments, whether you're listening or watching, and we'll go check it out. Yes. I wanna, we wanna see your personality, too.

Kris: [00:21:11] Yes. And please don't forget to follow the show, and if you go to YouTube, also subscribe there. That is how we get this podcast out there and how we grow the channel, and it's just so important that good quality content gets out there for people to help them.

Jaime: [00:21:28] And don't forget to submit your questions, too. You can either just post them, comment, or you can even email us at [email protected], and we will highlight you on the show. Give a little shout-out, how about that?

Kris: [00:21:43] I love it. Let's do it. Okay. Thank you. All

Jaime: [00:21:45] right. Thanks so much, Kris. Bye.

Brand & Growth Strategy for Experts Who Want to Stand Out

© 2026 Red Door Stories. All Rights Reserved.

Privacy Policy. Terms of Service. Disclaimer. StoryBrand Website Design by Red Door Stories